| Company | 100 gal | 150 gal | 200 gal | Last checked | Rating | Delivery | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Romeo's FuelSuffolk · Nassau Lowest todayPosted price $50 cancellation fee after order is placed | $5.349 | $5.299 | $5.229 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | Posted delivery schedule | Order |
| Precision Heating OilSuffolk ZIP 11706 cash = posted price minus the 8¢ cash-on-delivery discount the site advertises | $5.450cashcard $5.530 | $5.400cashcard $5.480 | $5.350cashcard $5.430 | Oct 17, 10:53 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Express COD (with Tragar)Suffolk · Nassau Posted price minimum order 100 gal; no cancellations; new customers: 5c/gal off first order (code NEW5) | $5.439 | $5.439 | $5.389 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | Same day if ordered by 10 AM | Order |
| L&H Fuel OilSuffolk Posted price | $5.539cashcard $5.609 | $5.439cashcard $5.509 | $5.389cashcard $5.459 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| All Island ComfortSuffolk · Nassau ZIP 11706 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Discount FuelSuffolk · Nassau · Queens ZIP 11706 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | 24-hr / emergency | Order |
| Domino Fuel Inc.Suffolk · Nassau · Queens ZIP 11706 | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | ★ 4.7 | Same day · 24/7 | Order |
| Bonilla's Fuel ServicesSuffolk Posted price | $5.659cashcard $5.709 | $5.609cashcard $5.659 | $5.559cashcard $5.609 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Anchor Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau Posted price | $5.799 | $5.729 | $5.699 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Bay Shore FuelSuffolk Posted price | $5.899 | $5.849 | $5.799 | Oct 17, 11:31 AM ET | — | — | Order |
| Tandy OilSuffolk Posted price taxes not included (Suffolk 2.5%); East End delivery | $6.190 | $6.090 | $6.090 | Oct 17, 11:04 AM ET | — | COD or automatic | Order |
| Aladdin Oil / Aladdin FuelSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | Full service or COD | Order |
| All Island FuelSuffolk · Nassau Check dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Bay Fuel Oil (Hart Home Comfort)Suffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | Automatic or COD | Order |
| JMB Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| John Taylor Heating Oil (Hendrickson Fuels)Suffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | ★ 5.0 | — | Order |
| John's Fuel OilSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Power Fuel OilSuffolk ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | 1–2 business days | Order |
| Sunrise FuelSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| Wise Choice Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau ZIP quote on dealer site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | Enter ZIP on site | — | — | — | Order |
| D&G Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau · Queens Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Devoe Fuel OilSuffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Family Fuel & Heating ServiceSuffolk · Nassau · Queens Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Order |
| JC Discount FuelSuffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| OK PetroleumSuffolk · Nassau Call or visit dealer site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | — | — | — | Visit site |
| Petro Home ServicesSuffolk · Nassau Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | Automatic delivery | Call |
| Suffolk OilSuffolk Call or visit dealer site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | Call or visit site | — | — | — | Visit site |
| Sunset Fuel (All Island Fuel of Mastic)Suffolk Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | — | Call |
| Tragar Home ServicesSuffolk · Nassau Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | Call for price | — | — | Automatic delivery | Call |
Prices are read automatically from each dealer's own website (for ZIP-priced dealers, from sample ZIPs in each county; only a ZIP code is ever entered).
Per gallon, before sales tax unless noted. cash = cash/COD price; card price shown under it when different. Prices older than 36 hours are marked stale.
Readings that fail our sanity checks (outside $2–$9/gal, or a jump of more than 15%) are held for review and not shown. Ratings and delivery notes come from our earlier research and may be out of date. Always confirm price and fees with the dealer.
Town pages in Suffolk County
RonkonkomaBay ShoreBrentwoodHuntingtonSmithtownPatchogueRiverheadMedfordHolbrookCommackLindenhurstCentereach