| Company | Last checked | Google rating | Delivery | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Romeo's FuelSuffolk · Nassau Lowest todayPosted price $50 cancellation fee after order is placed | $5.349 | $5.299 | $5.229 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.7 (3,173) | Posted delivery schedule | Order |
| All Island FuelSuffolk · Nassau Posted price Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $5.369cashcard $5.429 | $5.319cashcard $5.379 | $5.259cashcard $5.319 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.6 (368) | 7 days a week | Order |
| Express COD (with Tragar)Suffolk · Nassau Posted price minimum order 100 gal; no cancellations; new customers: 5c/gal off first order (code NEW5) | $5.439 | $5.439 | $5.389 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.6 (65) | Order by 10 AM | Order |
| OK PetroleumSuffolk · Nassau Posted price | $5.599 | $5.499 | $5.469 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.5 (59) | Schedule online | Order |
| At Your Service OilNassau · Queens Posted price | $5.710 | $5.550 | $5.510 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 2.0 (9) | Online ordering | Order |
| All Island ComfortSuffolk · Nassau Posted price Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 5.0 (32) | 24/7 same-day fills | Order |
| Discount FuelSuffolk · Nassau · Queens Posted price Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 2.3 (3) | Within 24 hours | Order |
| Domino Fuel Inc.Suffolk · Nassau · Queens Posted price Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $5.599 | $5.559 | $5.459 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.7 (800) | Same-day & 24/7 | Order |
| Oilex HeatingNassau Posted price $50 cancellation fee | $5.650 | $5.590 | $5.530 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.9 (287) | Same-day delivery | Order |
| Anchor Fuel OilSuffolk · Nassau Posted price | $5.799 | $5.729 | $5.699 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | — | Online ordering | Order |
| Bel-Mar OilNassau · Queens Posted price Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $5.850 | $5.790 | $5.750 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 3.8 (23) | 24-hour emergency | Order |
| Family Fuel & Heating ServiceSuffolk · Nassau Posted price COD price (tiers 100-149 / 150-199 / 200-299 gal); 300+ gal $5.799; full-service (contract) price $6.699 + $169.00 service contract | $5.899 | $5.849 | $5.819 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 4.8 (272) | Same-day when available | Order |
| Paragon OilNassau · Queens Posted price earliest delivery October 20th, 2026; Prices may vary, check your zipcode for an exact quote | $6.499 | $6.449 | $6.449 | Oct 17, 8:02 PM ET | ★ 3.0 (30) | Online ordering | Order |
About heating oil delivery in New Hyde Park
New Hyde Park is in Nassau County. The table above lists every dealer in our directory that names Nassau in its service area; a dealer may not deliver to every street, so check your address on the dealer's site or by phone. Prices are per gallon for COD (one-time) deliveries of 100, 150 and 200 gallons, as posted on each dealer's own website at the time shown.
Other Nassau County towns: Hempstead · Levittown · Massapequa · Hicksville · Freeport · Valley Stream · Long Beach · Garden City · Westbury · East Meadow · Baldwin · Bellmore · Merrick · Wantagh · Seaford · Massapequa Park · Bethpage · Plainview · Syosset · Oyster Bay · Glen Cove · Port Washington · Manhasset · Great Neck · Mineola · Floral Park · Elmont · Franklin Square · West Hempstead · Uniondale · Roosevelt · Oceanside · Rockville Centre · Lynbrook · Malverne · Lawrence · Inwood · Cedarhurst · Woodmere · Hewlett · Island Park · Carle Place · Jericho · Old Bethpage · Farmingdale · Locust Valley · Glen Head · Sea Cliff · Roslyn · Williston Park · East Rockaway · Woodbury · Point Lookout